| Platinum | La Terraza Mexican Grill & Bar |
| Gold | La Bamba Taco House |
| Silver | El Mazatlan Mexican Restaurant |
| Bronze | La Plaza Fiesta |
| Top Pick | Bonfire Wood Fire Cooking-Mankato |
| Top Pick | Catrine's Mexican Bar and Grill |
| Top Pick | El Agave |
| Top Pick | Giliberto's Mexican Taco Shop #10 |
| Top Pick | Taqueria Dona Tere |
| Top Pick | Zanz Mexican Restaurant |