| Platinum | Pappageorge Restaurant & Bar |
| Gold | Tav on the Ave |
| Silver | Dino's Pizzeria |
| Bronze | Jake's Stadium Pizza |
| Top Pick | El Mazatlan Mexican Restaurant |
| Top Pick | Jake's Pizza |
| Top Pick | Nolabelle Kitchen + Bar |
| Top Pick | Swiss and Madison |
| Top Pick | The Boulder Tap House - Mankato |
| Top Pick | Thunder Bar & Restaurant |